Can torture of terrorist suspects be justified

Many people believe that in such a situation, agents should do anything they can to find the bomb, including torturing the terrorist alan dershowitz, a harvard law professor therefore, should the united states be bound by all the conventions when interrogating terrorism suspects the bush administration's policy on. New poll finds majority of americans think torture was justified after 9/11 attacks a majority of americans think that the harsh interrogation techniques used on terrorism suspects after the sept 11, 2001 in general, 58 percent say the torture of suspected terrorists can be justified “often” or “sometimes. Download citation | can the torture of t | this article discusses allegations of the widespread use of torture on terrorist suspects and evidence that the us administration authorised and condoned its use its main focus is the subsequent and misplaced academic debate which concedes that tort. This article discusses allegations of the widespread use of torture on terrorist suspects and evidence that the us administration authorised and condoned its use its main focus is the subsequent and misplaced academic debate which concedes that torture in certain catastrophic circumstances is morally permissible in order. I think that torture against terrorist suspects can be justified i think that our military should use whatever means necessary in order to keep our country and our citizens safe i would also posit that when torture is used it should be after all other means have been exhausted there are many other countries that use torture and. The ticking time bomb scenario is a thought experiment that has been used in the ethics debate over whether torture can ever be justified as a thought experiment, there is no need that the scenario be plausible it need only serve to highlight ethical considerations the scenario can be formulated as follows: suppose that a. This essay would also examine the deontology approach to torture and make recommendations on other means of getting information and truths from terrorist suspects background to prohibition on torture torture and other cruel or inhumane treatment has been internationally outlawed since. By the way: it's important to understand that this answer does not justify the decision to torture, nor does it argue that we are justified in choosing the least bad option instead it should be interpreted rather differently - here are a couple of ways of doing it: torturing the terrorist is unethical and can't be justified, but it can be.

can torture of terrorist suspects be justified A utilitarian thinker may believe, when the overall outcome of lives saved due to torture are positive, torture can be justified the intended outcome of an action is held as the primary factor in determining its merit or morality the opposite view is the deontological, from greek deon (duty), which proposes general rules and.

In every war, information is a weapon in a “war against terrorism”, where the adversary wears no uniform and hides among the civilian population, information can matter even more but does that mean that torture can sometimes be justified to extract information the answer in international law is. Is it ever ethical for agents to torture a suspected terrorist if they believe that it will save lives dyck: torture really can't be justified you can get results in many different ways i recently heard an interrogator for the military say that he doesn't use rough techniques and he can get information but ultimately, it. Poll conducted the same week as brussels attacks found two-thirds supported torture of terrorism suspects, but the results should be read with caution according to a new poll, two out of every three american adults believe that torture against suspected terrorists can be justified the survey is timely.

A senior tory mp has said that torturing terrorists can “sometimes be justified” after theresa may condemned plans by donald trump to allow its use denying food to terrorist suspects and showing pictures of their comrades who had been blown up were among the techniques which could be used to. Despite tony blair's bizarre rantings, terrorism does not pose an 'existential' threat to our society reasonable people will disagree about when torture is justified but that, in some it seems extraordinary that we are willing to shoot terrorist suspects in order to save lives, but not to deprive them of sleep.

Under severe interrogations, with beatings, sleep deprivation, and isolation, almost everyone confessed, thereby providing public justification for the arrests[ 68] the widespread this is all to say that while torture of terrorist suspects indeed provides more data, it does not discriminate between truth and lies turning to the. Nearly two-thirds of americans say they believe torture can be justified to extract information from those suspected of planning attacks, a survey released wednesday found the march 22-28 online reuters/ipsos poll asked respondents if torture can be justified against suspected terrorists to obtain. Nearly two-thirds of americans believe torture can be justified to extract information from suspected terrorists, according to a reuters/ipsos poll, a level of support similar to that seen in countries like nigeria where militant attacks are common. For the threat posed by (say) a terrorist-bomber is either imminent, as in the case of a suicide-bomber, in which case there is however, this does not demonstrate that justified torturing of the guilty to save the innocent they threaten is.

Can torture of terrorist suspects be justified

A still-classified march 19, 2004, draft memo by the justice department authorized the central intelligence agency (cia) to render terrorism suspects out of alberto gonzalez—now the us attorney general—advised the white house that torturing al-qaeda terrorists in captivity abroad may be justified. Around the world, public opinion is divided about whether government- sponsored torture can ever be justified as part of efforts to prevent terrorist attacks countries with larger percentages of people who say their own governments would be justified in torturing terrorist suspects also tend to have larger.

  • About whether torture could ever be justified in those situations where it is most likely to be effective for legal, ethical changes in the relationship between torture and terrorism over time, which can be examined using different there are terrorist suspects and other prisoners in their custody for example.
  • The president chose not to condemn those who in the past may have used torture , a policy justified as looking forward not backwards, but the failure to do so has been so the question remains — should the us government torture terrorist suspects, or collude in having other countries do so for us.
  • Gonzales, the new attorney general, argued during his confirmation proceedings that the un convention against torture's ban on “cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment” of terrorist suspects does not apply to american interrogations of foreigners overseas perhaps surprisingly, the fiercest internal.

Tunisians, in shock and horror over the recent terrorist attacks, have demanded strong and determined measures to eliminate terrorism first, we strongly affirm that terrorism is an awful crime that can never be excused or justified torturing terrorism suspects does not help counterterrorism efforts. 41 (2001) jason s greenberg, notes & comments, torture of terrorist suspects in israel: the united nations for the purposes of this article, torture will be defined simply as the deliberate infliction of severe physical pain absolutely never justified, no matter how high the costs, even if it can save lives. It states explicitly that torture is never justified -- ''no exceptional circumstances whatsoever may be invoked as a justification for torture unlike the ''in this autumn of anger, jonathan alter commented in newsweek not long after the terrorist attacks, ''a liberal can find his thoughts turning to -- torture. Justified torture preventing terrorism often requires a choice of evils: to target terrorists and their leaders, knowing civilians will be killed to collect massive amounts of private data in an effort to track terrorists to detain potential terrorists without trial but perhaps no choice of evils is more controversial than.

can torture of terrorist suspects be justified A utilitarian thinker may believe, when the overall outcome of lives saved due to torture are positive, torture can be justified the intended outcome of an action is held as the primary factor in determining its merit or morality the opposite view is the deontological, from greek deon (duty), which proposes general rules and.
Can torture of terrorist suspects be justified
Rated 4/5 based on 34 review